The attorney shared, “Your ability to translate the complex pharmacokinetics of transdermal delivery into a clear narrative of negligence was the turning point in our negotiations. We couldn't have secured this result without your clinical roadmap.”
My Most Memorable CLNC Case involved the death of an elderly patient receiving palliative home care for chronic pain. The death occurred following the unauthorized alteration of a prescribed fentanyl patch by the home health nurse. This case illustrates how a well-intentioned but clinically unsound nursing decision can result in catastrophic harm.
Deviations from the Standards of Care
During a home visit, the nurse determined that the patient appeared excessively lethargic and independently attempted to reduce the prescribed dose of the fentanyl patch by cutting it in half. Deviations from the standards of care include:
Defense Arguments
The defense focused on causation issues. They argued that the patient’s underlying respiratory insufficiency and other comorbidities contributed substantially to the death. They also characterized the nurse’s actions as a benevolent intent to protect the patient from over-sedation rather than a willful disregard for patient safety. This defense is flawed because good intentions do not establish adherence to the standards of care.
CLNC® Services Provided
As the Certified Legal Nurse Consultant for the plaintiff attorney, I provided the following services:
Case Outcome
This case resulted in a significant out-of-court settlement in favor of the plaintiff’s estate. My analysis revealed that the nurse had documented “Cut patch in half to decrease dose.” This evidence made a defense of the facts nearly impossible, leading to the rapid settlement. The attorney shared, “Your ability to translate the complex pharmacokinetics of transdermal delivery into a clear narrative of negligence was the turning point in our negotiations. We couldn’t have secured this result without your clinical roadmap.”
Professional Business Impact
This case strengthened my reputation as an expert in medication errors and home health nursing standards. From a business perspective, this case became a turning point in my CLNC business. The revenue and professional momentum generated by the case allowed me to transition from part time to full time.
Lessons for CLNC® Consultants
Impact on the Plaintiff’s Family
My work product contributed to justice and accountability. While the settlement cannot replace their loved one, the legal recognition of the deviations from the standards of care provided closure for the family. It also impacted the home health agency’s policy to implement mandatory retraining for all staff regarding high-alert medications. The family responded positively knowing that the corrective action could help prevent a similar event from happening to another patient.
Click here for Memorable Case guidelines and thought starters.